top of page
Search

R v Lafferty: Why "I was scared" isn't enough in a self-defence case

Writer: Stephanie Heyens
Stephanie Heyens
10 minutes ago
3 min read

On November 10, 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada upheld Hannah Lafferty's conviction for dangerous driving causing death. The Court ruled from the bench the day it heard the appeal, substantially agreeing with the majority of the Northwest Territories Court of Appeal. It didn't change the law on self-defence. But the case shows how much a self-defence claim depends on details that only the accused person can give.

What happened

In April 2022, Ms. Lafferty was sitting in her truck in a Yellowknife apartment parking lot. Another woman came up, opened the driver's door and stepped onto the running board. That woman later said she was trying to grab the key. Ms. Lafferty hit the gas and swerved "like a snake" to throw the other woman off. The open door hit a bystander, Germaine Mantla, who later died.

Ms. Lafferty admitted her driving was dangerous. She said she acted in self-defence because she was afraid the other woman would hurt her.

Why self-defence failed

The trial judge believed Ms. Lafferty was truly afraid but found the fear wasn't reasonable. There was no weapon, no threat, no history of violence between the two women, and no words were exchanged. Even if there was a threat, the trial judge found that swerving a pickup through a parking lot wasn't a reasonable response when there were other options, like calling for help.

The majority of the Court of Appeal agreed. Ms. Lafferty had described one fear, being hurt, so the trial judge only had to look at that fear. The trial judge didn't have to consider a different fear Ms. Lafferty never described, such as the other woman taking control of the truck.

Ms. Lafferty also had a serious shoulder injury from a few weeks before. It was part of the evidence, but the trial judge's reasons said little about it. The appeal judges disagreed on whether that mattered, and the Supreme Court sided with the majority.

What this means if you claim self-defence

The law asks three things. Did you reasonably believe someone was using or threatening force against you or someone else? Did you act to protect yourself or that person? Was what you did reasonable in the situation?

The first two are about what was going on in your head, and usually you're the only one who can tell the court. As this case shows, the court judges your defence by the fear you actually describe.

That's why I ask my clients a lot of questions in a self-defence case. "I was scared" isn't enough. The court needs to hear:

  • exactly what you saw and heard, moment by moment

  • what you thought the other person was about to do, and why

  • what you already knew about that person

  • what you were afraid would happen if you didn't act

  • what other options you had, and why they didn't seem realistic

  • how your size, health or injuries affected what you could do

Whether your response was reasonable depends on things like how serious and how close the threat was, whether there was a weapon, the size and strength of the people involved, your history with the other person, and whether your response was in proportion. A fact that never comes out at trial can't be weighed.

Getting all of that into evidence takes time. I go over the events with my clients many times and check their account against the Crown's evidence, to pin down every fact that matters.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Convicted Without Evidence?

Russell Brand was just convicted in the UK of rape and sexual assault. The allegations went back decades to the late 1990s and 2000s. On November 5, 2026, a London jury found him guilty of one count o

 
 
 

Comments


© Copyright 2026

bottom of page